Giftedness · Autism Spectrum Disorder

Giftedness or Asperger syndrome / ASD?

Feeling out of step with others, heightened sensitivity, intense interests or atypical cognitive functioning can suggest several possibilities. Comparing High Intellectual Potential with the profile historically called “Asperger syndrome”, now included within Autism Spectrum Disorder, helps clarify their similarities and differences.

Video in French. The article below is available in English.

Two forms of functioning that can share certain traits

The term “Asperger syndrome” remains widely used in everyday language and by many people to describe themselves. In current diagnostic classifications, it is included within Autism Spectrum Disorder. Some characteristics can resemble those of giftedness, and the two can also coexist.

Similarities and differences between HIP and ASD / the Asperger profile

These comparisons describe possible tendencies. On their own, they are not diagnostic criteria.

High Intellectual Potential ASD / historically Asperger profile
Feels out of step with othersFeels out of step with others
Strong empathy cognitive empathy (can identify other people’s emotions) Low cognitive empathy (has difficulty identifying other people’s emotions)
Strong empathy emotional empathy (feels other people’s emotions) Strong emotional empathy (feels other people’s emotions)
Emotional sensitivity, possible sensory hypersensitivity Sensory hypersensitivity, possible emotional hypersensitivity
Varied emotions that are easily expressedEmotions not expressed verbally
Great sensitivity to injusticeGreat sensitivity to injustice
IQ above 130No intellectual disability
Crystallised intelligence higher than task-processing speed Crystallised intelligence higher than task-processing speed
Verbal intelligence higher than non-verbal intelligence Verbal intelligence higher than non-verbal intelligence
Emotional intelligence high Low emotional intelligence
Little or no clumsinessPhysical clumsiness
Intense, varied interestsIntense, restricted interests (extremely knowledgeable about one or a few subjects)
Comfortable multitaskingComfortable doing one task at a time
If distracted, easily returns to the taskIf distracted, finds it difficult to return to the task
Vivid imaginationDifficulty imagining, or imagination limited to one area
Branching thoughtSequential, linear thinking
Perfectionism, sometimes excessive No perfectionism, except in areas of intense interest
Introverted or extrovertedNeeds long periods alone
Needs change and noveltyFinds change difficult
May have experienced bullyingMay have experienced bullying

Can someone have both HIP and autism?

Yes. For some people, identifying giftedness alone explains part of their functioning, while their relationships, need for solitude, sensory characteristics or need for stability remain unexplained. Exploring Autism Spectrum Disorder as well can then offer a fuller understanding.

Video in French. The article below is available in English.

High Emotional Potential and ASD: how can we understand the difference?

Descriptions of HEP often emphasise great subtlety in perceiving and understanding emotions and relationships. In ASD, certain aspects of social communication can function differently, without implying an absence of emotions or empathy. Examining overall functioning is therefore much more useful than a simple contrast between “empathetic” and “unempathetic”.

Video in French. The article below is available in English.

Frequently asked questions

Can someone have HIP and autism at the same time?

Yes. These two dimensions are not mutually exclusive and can coexist in the same person.

Is the term Asperger still used?

It remains widely used in everyday language and by some people to describe themselves, although current diagnostic classifications include it within Autism Spectrum Disorder.

Is a table of characteristics enough to distinguish them?

No. There are many similarities, and individual profiles vary greatly. A comprehensive assessment is needed when diagnostic clarification is sought.

Do you recognise several characteristics of both profiles in yourself?

Screening can be a first step towards finding out which possibility deserves further exploration, rather than drawing conclusions from a few similarities alone.